
Introduction
The topic of handouts has arisen because of
the huge photocopying bills incurred by some departments and the need
to find some alternative resources to the ubiquitous handout. Some
students have come to rely on handouts, instead of making their own
notes, reading or listening or even thinking. We do not want to
encourage too much passivity in students by the overuse of this
resource: we want them to take away their own notes. This seems an
opportune moment therefore to rethink its usage.
A handout is a paperbased resource used to
support teaching and learning which can free students from excessive
notetaking or supplement information not easily available elsewhere.
Ideally it should aid learning and may increase attention and
motivation and help students to follow the development of an idea or
argument. The first task therefore is to clarify the aim in using any
handout. The desired outcome will affect the information, its
quantity, presentation and, crucially, when you distribute
it.
Handouts come in several guises and I am
going to focus on those most commonly used. I will discuss how to
produce and use these effectively and list their advantages and
disadvantages.
Press
to return to menu
Why
use a handout?
A useful question to ask is "Why am I using
a handout at this point of the session?" Is this material freely
available elsewhere? Have I checked to see if this information
included in any text book recommended for the module/course. How do I
know students will read this (weighty) material, unless I provide
time in the session and I can actually see them reading?
There are several reasons for using a
handout. It can:
- provide definitions for the more jargon
ridden subjects;
- provide background information or
detailed information, e.g. statistics, which are not readily
available elsewhere;
- put forward a point of view;
- outline a course of action;
- pose conceptual questions;
- provide a case study for problemsolving
or discussion;
- provide a complex diagram rather than
students copying from the OHP;
- give a step by step instruction for
teaching a skill or running a laboratory exercise;
- outline the session with a series of
bullet points per topic area;
- produce a hard copy of the
transparencies used by reducing the print size of your overhead
transparencies which can be printed down one half of the page,
allowing students space to add their own comments or questions
alongside.
Press
to return to menu
When
not to use handouts
- Transcripts of lectures: these could be
either on audio tape or one paper copy available in the library
which could be for reference only. This would however encourage
students to be passive learners and discourage attendance at
lectures. One advantage is that it would help the genuine
absentees and provides a reference for students who might wish to
check a difficult concept or modify their notes. If students opt
to photocopy the lecture transcript they are the ones bearing the
cost! To paraphrase Graham Gibbs in one of his "53 Interesting
Ways ..." books: if you provide copious and thorough handouts,
what is to motivate the student to attend the lecture when one
student can attend to "pick up the handouts"?
- Chapters from books: this is expensive
for a large group of, say, 200. It may be cheaper for the library
to buy multiple copies.
Press
to return to menu
Distribution
and Timing
Do the students need to prepare by reading
the material in advance of the session? 'If so, hand it out the
previous week do not use up precious lecture time on having students
read long or complex handouts. If read in advance, students
can/should bring questions to the session that they want
answered.
If you want the students to read a short
handout during the session which supplements the content of the
lecture/session, time the distribution carefully (you don't want to
compete for their attention while you are making key points). Make
sure that at least they do read it by posing some questions or small
group activities which relate to the passage. This will help test
their understanding.
- At the end of the session?
If you delay the distribution till the end
of the session, or give it to students to take away to read, how will
you know if it ever gets read? Consider posing some specific
questions which the students should be prepared to answer the
following week. Advantages: supporting detail can be covered which
was omitted from the session; provides further tasks for the students
to undertake (reading, answering questions) again this helps to test
understanding. Finally, only you can decide when is the optimum time
to distribute the handout, bearing in mind the comments made
above.
Press
to return to menu
Types of
Handouts
- Uncompleted or gapped handout: this is a
handout with gaps which students fill in.
Advantages:
- the handout contains key points which
will be the same for all students;
- the student has to listen actively to
complete the notes;
- it spares student tedious notemaking
and thereby should generate greater concentration on the
lecture;
- partially provides correct
information but relies on the students completing the
information either from the lecture itself, or from further
reading thus removing the passive element in a situation where
all the information is provided.
Examples:
- complete the plotting of a
graph
- complete the labelling of a diagram
(Note: complicated diagrams are best provided on a handout
rather than an OHT)
- under a heading, ask students to
complete half a dozen lines of notes.
- incomplete calculations which the
student must finish.
- complete a flow chart for a
process.
- Skeletal notes: literally the
bare bones of a session (key statement, a definition, a diagram)
with gaps/spaces and omissions to be completed by the student. The
advantages are similar to the gapped handout.
- Assessment criteria: guides to the
assessment for a particular module. If you are including self or
peer observation among your assessment methods, students will need
information on the agreed criteria.
Advantage:
- essential information is given to all
students and is available for reference.
- Information sheets: there are several
areas of the institution where a guide would be useful, e.g.
administration of the course (term dates, semester dates,
assessment hand-in dates etc.); a teaching scheme for the module;
computer and library information - the list is a long one!
Advantage:
- essential information is given to all
students and is available for reference.
Press
to return to menu
General Principles on
the Production of Handouts
- Reading handouts: give students
activities to complete or questions to answer whilst reading (this
helps concentration), e.g. list four points X makes about Y;
identify two/three key issues in this section; what further
questions do you need to ask to understand this
section/para/chapter?
- Use the what, how, why, when and where
questions as appropriate.
- Avoid long, dense handouts. Make them
look attractive: leave spaces etc.
- Make sure the appearance of the material
is up to standard. Try to keep handouts as concise as
possible.
- If, after considering the alternatives
suggested, you find it necessary to photocopy substantial extracts
from books, have you remembered to check the issue of copyright?
If you think you may be infringing the law, consult the guidelines
which are displayed by photocopiers.
- Print size: use the smallest print size
which is manageable for the average reader.
Press
to return to menu
Alternatives to
Handouts
- Library: would it be better (and cheaper
in the long term) for the library to buy more copies of key texts
rather than photocopying whole chapters of books etc.? Some copies
can be reference only, or one week loan.
- Internet and Website: have you the
skills to put your lectures or materials on the web so that
students can access these at their leisure, and repeatedly if
necessary? Much administrative information could be put on the web
and updated as necessary.
- Email: is it worth sending vital
information to students via Email? Are there enough resources to
implement this together with the internet and web?
- Module guide: if there is really no
alternative to handouts, can these be collected and put into a
form of guide? Should students be charged for this? (After all it
is taking the place of a conventional "text" book
Press
to return to menu
References:
- Gibbs G, Habeshaw S et al (1995) 53
Interesting things to do in your lectures (TES)
- McShane, Dalene (1998) Presenting
Information Visually (EIC Guide)